(NOTE: Watch her full one-on-one interview with NBC Chicago in the video player above)
Chicago's former top doctor sat down with NBC Chicago for an exclusive television interview Monday, just days after her controversial firing that she revealed left even her surprised, but not for the reason many might think.
In her interview, Arwady said it wasn't that she was fired, but how she was fired that felt "really disturbing."
"So I got a call from the chief of staff, and I met with him and he said, 'This is a hard discussion, but you are being terminated,'" Arwady said. "And I said, 'That is not a major surprise at this point.' Just knowing the mayor, of course, has the opportunity to bring on whomever he wants. But then what really was disturbing to me, was I said, 'Let's talk timeline,' and he said, 'It's effective immediately.'"
Arwady was forced to exit her position without being able to address the change with her team or transition her successor into the role.
"I never had a chance to talk to my team, and that really was that was the one thing I asked for in that meeting. I asked, 'Can I at least send an email?'" Arwady said. "I've really tried to model transparency for my team. I think that's how you build trust and I was not able to do that. And, you know, that was my largest concern in a lot of ways. I absolutely love my team and I felt strongly about being able to share even bad news with them directly."
Arwady served as the commissioner for the Chicago Department of Public Health throughout the coronavirus pandemic alongside former Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot. She became known for holding regular press conferences as well as weekly live "Ask Arwady" sessions on Facebook and Twitter to answer real-time COVID questions.
Local
In an email Friday evening, Mayor Brandon Johnson's office confirmed Arwady's firing, but didn't provide a reason or any details.
Earlier this year, following Lightfoot's reelection loss, questions swirled about whether Arwady would stay on in the next administration. In an interview with NBC Chicago health reporter Lauren Petty in mid-April, the CDPH commissioner said she was “hopeful” to continue on as the department's leader. But one month earlier Johnson indicated that he would seek a leadership change.
Feeling out of the loop? We'll catch you up on the Chicago news you need to know. Sign up for the weekly Chicago Catch-Up newsletter.
"This was not entirely unexpected," Arwady said. "You know, [Johnson has] been in office for three months and we want him to be successful. Even now, I want this mayor and his team to be successful. And I kept hoping that there would be an opportunity to talk with him and meet with him, explain the work that the department does. And although I was sometimes in the same room with him in a cabinet meeting, for example, we never exchanged three words. And so again, outcome not a surprise, but the manner of it I think was unnecessarily destabilizing to my department."
(Watch her full one-on-one interview with NBC Chicago in the video player above)
What was behind her firing?
There has been speculation that Arwady's firing centered around her response to reopening schools during the COVID pandemic despite some opposition from the city's teachers union, which expressed concerns about return to school. A former teacher himself, Johnson's candidacy for mayor was backed by the CTU.
"COVID was a very difficult time for the entire country and it was a very hard job for me. Whether you are a business owner or you were a childcare provider, it was difficult for all of us and created a great deal of stress. And what I've committed myself to do is to make sure that we have, again, a very collaborative approach of how we assess all of our sister agencies in our departments," Johnson said when asked about his decision during an unrelated press conference Monday, adding that "every single administration has to be prepared for transition."
Arwady said she didn't know much about the reasoning for her firing or whether it was tied to the reopening of city schools.
"I don't know. And frankly, I don't want to know," she said. "I told my colleagues around the country that, you know, at the end of the day, I'm actually a little bit proud to now have joined the ranks of the hundreds of public health leaders who ultimately lost their jobs for making data-driven decisions during COVID. And I, again, I want this mayor to be successful even now."
One thing is certain, she feels the city made the right call.
"So I believe always in looking at what the data shows us and we had a natural experiment here in Chicago where our the largest parochial system in the country, the Archdiocese of Chicago, was open for a semester when Chicago Public Schools were not. We also had the opportunity to watch around the country where many, many, many schools were in fact opened," Arwady said. "And I had a dedicated team from the very earliest days of COVID dedicated to youth, because we knew this was going to be a challenge. We looked at the data, we looked at what was happening in daycares and and school camps and all the other places where children were still getting care, and we saw that there was not an increased risk to children or to their teachers for being in school. And so... I'm a pediatrician and an internal medicine doc. I was concerned and I think the data has shown this to be true, that there were a lot of negative consequences for kids being out of their routines, not being in school. So, you know, I would have made that same decision again, even knowing that this was going to be the outcome."
The future of CPDH
Arwady said the circumstances surrounding her departure left the city's public health department surrounded in uncertainty.
"I am very honest when I say what I care about is public, not politics," Arwady told NBC Chicago's Chief Political Reporter Mary Ann Ahern. "I don't know what was happening behind the scenes. What I can say is I'm respectful of this decision. I'm just concerned that the way it was made will actually make it harder to bring in a new commissioner, like someone who really understands public health and has the expertise and the knowledge to to lead this department. That's at the end of the day, really what I care about."
But despite the unexpected abruptness, Chicago's former top doctor said she is still willing to help with the transition, should her help be requested.
"Frankly, whenever a new commissioner eventually is named, I will be happy to talk with that person and I will be happy to explain some of what we've built up," she said. "And I'm really proud of what we've built up over my eight years at CDPH. And I think that there are a lot of things that happen at the health department beyond just sort of the obvious public-facing pieces."
As for who could replace her, Arwady wasn't clear and Johnson has not yet given a public indication of his potential pick.
"I have been telling my team for some time that the city of Chicago has a vetting process when it is looking at leaders," Arwady said. "I am less concerned about any drama that may be happening on social media. I am more concerned about making sure that whoever leads the health department has real public health knowledge. And so that is really what I am interested in. That, I know, is what the mayor has said he is interested in, and I'm looking forward to see who who will be named. But it needs to be somebody who understands public health and the operations of how to protect the city, not just around mental health, not just around COVID, around the amazing range of things that the health department gets to work on."
COVID update and booster shot advice
Concerns are starting to rise as the Chicago area reports what some experts have called a "mini-surge" in cases and hospitalizations begin to experience small increases.
Last week, the Illinois Department of Public Health said the state remained at low levels of COVID transmission, but officials are also urging the public to remain cautious and to begin preparations for a turn toward colder weather.
Does that mean residents should get a booster shot now or wait until the fall when an updated vaccine is expected?
"You should wait," Arwady said. "We anticipate a new vaccine available probably late-September or early-October. That is going to be an update that will be the newest version to help fight off omicron, the type of omicron subvariants we're seeing more recently. And it'll be important that everybody get that booster," Arwady said. "That's what helps get us through the fall. That's what's turned COVID. Even during this time of increased cases, we are seeing zero to one deaths a day. We are seeing handfuls of Chicagoans being hospitalized. When I compare that to the more than 50 Chicagoans a day who were dying during COVID, the, at some points, more than 300 Chicagoans being newly hospitalized every day, it is vaccines and it is treatments that have turned this into a disease that we can coexist with."
Guidance is expected from the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices in the coming weeks, according to a statement.
Her message to Chicago
Arwady said she's not sure what's next for her, but "Chicago is my home."
"This is the place that I care about the most. So regardless of whether I end up working here, whether I end up working on public health issues, you know, in some other setting or nationally, this will stay my home. This will be the place that I care about. This will be the public health department that I care the most about. And I think that is likely to be true for the rest of my life."
Her final message as she exits her role for Chicago is "not focused on the way that it ended," but rather looking forward.
"I want people to know that they have an amazing team protecting their health at the Chicago Department of Public Health. I want them to know that we do a lot more than COVID. I am so proud of the work that we have done on opioids, on HIV, on infant mortality. I am so excited about the healthy Chicago equity zones and the ways in which we've gotten creative to bring vaccines to people at home," she said. "I have a team or I had a team that is creative and innovative and excellent at solving problems, and they care so deeply about protecting the health of Chicago. I want Chicagoans to know that public health is not going anywhere just because COVID is on the downturn right now. And we have to sustain and fund public health departments long-term and make sure that we are as prepared as we can be for whatever is coming next. And I think finally, I want Chicagoans to know that I have loved loved being in this role. It has been such an honor for me, really, the honor of my life. I'm an infectious disease nerd. I love working on outbreaks. I never wanted something like COVID to hit Chicago, but for that to happen at the time when I was in a leadership role in the city that I love with an amazing team, it has been the honor of my life. I am not focused on the way that it ended. I am focused on the future and helping this mayor be successful, support public health and really make sure that the things I care about stay strong in Chicago."
