Dismissed: A 6-month investigation of Chicago sex crime arrests & convictions

Dismissed: A 6-month investigation of Chicago sex crime arrests & convictions

Sexual assault charges were never filed or were dropped in favor of non-sex charges time and time again, NBC 5 Investigates found 

NBC 5 Investigates spent six months reviewing police records and examining court documents to find out how often allegations involving sex are never charged, never tried or simply disappear.

We looked at every sex-related arrest by Chicago police from 2018 to 2023 then cross-referenced each with records in Cook County criminal court. Our team read through every narrative in every court case – hundreds of accounts of sex assaults, rapes, incest and other sex-related crimes.

In all, NBC 5 Investigates examined more than 21,000 reported sex crimes over six years and found a small fraction led to an arrest.

Of the few offenders who were convicted, nearly half walked out of court with no prison time or pled down to a charge that did not require them to register as a sex offender.

Dismissed: Behind the NBC 5/Telemundo Chicago investigation

Over the course of a wide variety of stories reported by the NBC Chicago and Telemundo Chicago investigative teams over recent years, our reporters and producers noticed a recurring theme: Case after case of alleged sexual assault or abuse that never resulted in an arrest, was dismissed in court or was pled down in court to a non-sex conviction, such as battery or disorderly conduct, that bore no indication that someone was initially charged with a sex crime. Read the complete story here.

A six-month investigation found four out of every five people arrested in Chicago for a sexual assault, rape or other sex-related crime get their sex charges dismissed. The findings are disturbing on a topic that is difficult to talk about but so important to be informed. NBC 5 Investigates' Bennett Haeberle reports.

Part 1: Thousands of sexual assault cases die each year inside Chicago’s justice system

Thousands of sexual assault cases never saw an arrest, never made it to court or were dismissed once they got there, a six-month investigation of sex crimes reported to police revealed. Read the full story here.

In the first installment of “Dismissed,” NBC 5 Investigates’ Bennett Haeberle uncovered the startling details behind our six-month investigation into reported sex crimes and spoke with an assault survivor whose experience mirrored that of countless other victims.

Part 2: Racial disparities and the difficulty of prosecuting sexual assault cases

In the second installment of "Dismissed," NBC 5 Investigates explored a racial disparity among victims and why a question of credibility can undermine so many cases. Read the full story here.

As part of NBC 5 Investigates and Telemundo Chicago's six-month investigation, our team explored a racial disparity among victims and why these cases can be hard to prosecute. NBC Chicago's Bennett Haeberle reports.

Part 3: How Chicago's sex crime conviction rate compares to other cities

Our investigation found a very low rate of sex crime convictions in Chicago, but what about other major U.S. cities? Read our complete findings here.

An unprecedented investigation by NBC 5 Investigates found sexual assault cases in Chicago rarely led to an arrest and almost never led to a sex crime conviction with prison time, NBC Chicago's Bennett Haeberle reports.

NBC 5 Investigates has compiled an extensive list of resource for survivors in Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin, along with information on ways you can advocate for change and links to previous investigations regarding sex crimes on college campuses and local coaches accused of abusing their players and students. The page can be found here.

If you are the survivor of a sexual assault or sexual violence and want to tell your story or comment on our NBC 5 Investigates / Telemundo Chicago Investiga series, “Dismissed,” please contact us. You can leave a message on the NBC 5 Investigates tip line at 312-836-1441, or you can send our investigative team an email at this link. 

Illinois budget includes $20M aimed at repairing cuts to sexual assault crisis services

When state lawmakers in Springfield approved a spending plan in the wee hours of the morning this week, it included a $20 million injection of funds meant to shore up federal cuts that led to layoffs and forced rape crisis centers across Illinois to close. The news of the state funding approval comes less than a week after NBC 5 Investigates’ series "Dismissed" exposed how reported sexual assaults in Chicago rarely led to an arrest and conviction. Read more here.

When state lawmakers in Springfield approved a spending plan in the wee hours of the morning this week, it included a $20 million injection of funds meant to shore up federal cuts that led to layoffs and forced rape crisis centers across Illinois to close. Bennett Haeberle has the details.

Additional contributions
Photography and editing: DS Shin / NBC Chicago
Design and development: Alex Ford, Annetta Stogniew & Nelson Hsu / NBC

Contact Us